Dread Scott, What is the Proper Way to Display a US Flag?, 1989. Detail from installation. Viewers stood on the flag to write in a comment book. Before exhibiting at the School of the Art Institute of Chicago, Scott worked with lawyers and civil liberties groups who studied the recent Texas v. Johnson Supreme Court case to ensure First Amendment protection. Though arrested in the controversy, charges were dismissed, and the work ultimately helped strengthen constitutional protections for symbolic speech. Photo courtesy of the artist.
The Arts, Courage, and Consequence
Risk Is Real. Fear Is Bigger.
A practical framework to separate imagined catastrophe from genuine consequence before you speak out.
Five Questions to Ask Yourself
You have something urgent to say. A political message that won’t stay quiet. But the fear whispers: What will it cost me?
That fear is real, but it’s often bigger than the actual risk. These questions will help you separate imagined catastrophe from genuine consequence so your choice is informed, not just afraid.
1. What’s my employment situation?
Higher risk: You work for a politically sensitive employer, in a conservative or liberal area mismatched with your message, or in an at-will state with no union protection.
Lower risk: You’re self-employed, work in a creative field that values free expression, or have documented anti-retaliation policies.
Reality check: Most U.S. employees can be fired for what they post, but termination campaigns usually hit the extreme or high-visibility cases, not thoughtful political art.
2. What’s my financial cushion?
Higher risk: You live paycheck to paycheck with no savings.
Lower risk: You have three to six months of emergency funds or alternate income streams.
Reality check: Economic vulnerability is the biggest silencer. If losing your job could make you homeless, that’s not paranoia, it’s math. You may want to wait, or use anonymity until you’re more secure.
3. What’s my community context?
Higher risk: You live in a small town where everyone knows you, your family relies on community ties, or you’re in a tight-knit professional network.
Lower risk: You’re in a diverse city, have supportive chosen family, or work in fields that welcome provocative art.
Reality check: Social backlash is loud but rarely permanent. Outcries often fade faster than we fear.
4. What exactly am I saying?
Higher risk: Doxxing, ridicule, threats of violence, disinformation, or targeting protected groups.
Lower risk: Criticizing policies, satire, sharing lived experience, or creating art around controversial issues.
Reality check: Know the line between provocative political art and speech that crosses legal or ethical boundaries.
5. Am I in a protected class speaking about my own oppression?
Lower risk: Some legal protections cover speech about discrimination you’ve personally experienced.
Check: If you’re organizing with coworkers about workplace conditions, you may have National Labor Relations Act protections.
Reality check: Legal protections exist, but enforcing them takes resources most individual creators don’t have. Plus, the rule of law is under siege and Americans are living the fallout.
The Courage Calculation
After assessment, you face a choice. Sometimes the risks are too high right now and that’s okay. Strategic silence while you build resources isn’t cowardice.
But often the catastrophe you imagine is unlikely. Yes, there may be consequences. But they’re survivable. And the cost of silence (to your integrity, your community, the change that needs your voice) may be greater than the cost of speaking.
No responses yet